J-STD-001 & IPC-A-610 Updates for Conformal Coating: An Insider's Guide


Reading time ( words)

The reference standards used by the electronics industry are under constant review to ensure they reflect the latest technologies and methods. The usage of conformal coatings is growing and the quality of these coatings come under increasing scrutiny.

SMART Group recently offered a “direct from the committee” technical guide to the changes being made to J-STD-001 and IPC-A-610, presented by Doug Pauls, Principal Materials and Process engineer at Rockwell Collins and chair of IPC Cleaning and Cleanliness Committees, in a webinar organised and moderated by Bob Willis.

“Never let a bunch of soldering people make up a spec on conformal coatings!” was Pauls’ opening comment, with reference to the conformal coating requirements defined in J-STD-001 and IPC-A-610. “Inspection of conformal coatings is not the same as inspection of solder joints, and there has been far too much emphasis on cosmetics. We have spent too much time, and a lot of non-value-added work, in trying to achieve cosmetic perfection.”

Pauls explained that the leadership of J-STD-001 and IPC-A-610 had asked the conformal coating committees to rationalise and clarify the workmanship and inspection standards. “It needed some work!” The revisions to J-STD-001 were proposed to the committee in January 2014 and became part of the published standard in August 2014. As well as an expanded conformal coating section, IPC J-STD-001F included revised appendices, Appendix C offering guidance on objective evidence of material compatibility, which was of particular relevance if a user chose for practical reasons not to follow the exact recommendations of the vendor’s data sheet. “If you are doing something different, do your homework to make sure the end product exhibits the specified reliability.”

Procedures for mixing and curing were a case in point, for example extending the effective shelf life of an opened container by blanketing the contents with argon was an acceptable procedure provided it was properly evaluated and documented. The prevention of silicone contamination by avoiding the use of ovens otherwise used for curing silicone compounds was a critical issue.

Pauls reviewed precautions to be taken when conformal coating on glass-bodied components, and the importance of keeping coating fillets to a minimum on BGAs to avoid CTE and Young’s Modulus failures on thermal cycling. He also discussed designated areas for coverage, keep-out zones and tolerances, all with reference to the assembly drawing and documentation, and the avoidance of contaminating mating surfaces of connectors.

Coating thickness measurement had been a contentious issue. Variations were inevitable on and around components, and the use of representative process control coupons was recommended. Wet thickness measurements were permissible provided it was documented that these could be directly correlated to dry thickness. If required thickness was not specified in the drawing, Table 10.1 of J-STD-001F gave default values for various coating types.

An even more contentious issue was the assessment of completeness of coating coverage, and the homogeneity and completeness of cure. The latter could only be determined by instrumental methods such as differential scanning calorimetry or thermogravimetric analysis. The former was judged by visual inspection, although not to solder joint criteria and not with a higher magnification than x4. Coatings containing fluorescent tracers could be inspected for completeness of coverage under UV black light.

Share




Suggested Items

The ‘Intel’ on Advanced Packaging Options

11/29/2022 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007
Dr. Tom Rucker is vice president in technology development at Intel and was a keynote speaker at the IPC Advanced Packaging Symposium, which helped set the table for the rest of the agenda. Tom understands this “radical and seismic” shift in terms of technology and breaks down what it means for the semiconductor and PCB fab industries. There’s absolutely a place at the table for PCB fabricators, but what are the first steps?

Brian O'Leary: Organizing to Meet e-Mobility in the Market

11/28/2022 | Real Time with...SMTAI
Brian O’Leary, head of Indium's e-Mobility & Infrastructure, reacts to SMTAI’s keynote delivered by John Thomas of Autel. The title of the keynote presentation was "The Electronic Vehicle (EV) Conundrum" which addressed the sheer scale of the transition to e-Mobility that we are now undertaking. In this interview, O’Leary discusses some of the technical challenges faced in product development by Indium (and everyone else) as well as the new IPC e-Mobility council. Participation in the council is open to everyone.

Advanced Packaging Symposium: Looking in the Rearview Mirror

11/23/2022 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007
Matt Kelly had the vision and Jan Vardaman set the tone for the IPC Advanced Packaging Symposium, Oct. 11-13 in Washington, D.C. So, did they accomplish their goals? What were the real takeaways from the event, and what can we expect to see next? Spoiler alert: Matt and Jan came away impressed in more ways than one.



Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007 | IPC Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.